Main menu

Pages

Differences between a programmed economy and a market economy

What is a market economy?



A market economy is an economic system in which individual companies or the private sector make economic decisions about a wide range of factors related to goods. The laws of supply and demand play an important role in economic decision-making.





The prices of goods are set and sometimes agreed upon, between sellers and buyers. In this system, goods are sold at the highest price, i.e., the highest reasonable price at which consumers would buy the goods.




Based on the theory of supply and demand, a market economy is one in which land, capital, goods, and labor are owned by individuals or companies, goods and services are provided according to consumer preferences, and when demand is high, goods are produced at the maximum price consumers can afford, thus making more profit.




Advantages of a Market Economy



Own most of the goods and services and can determine the price at which they are bought and sold, giving priority to profit. You are free to sell, buy, or produce in the market.




Take more consumer preferences into account. If goods are produced according to consumers' preferences, then there may be an upper limit to the price of goods that consumers can buy. In a market economy, efficient producers are favored and rewarded for producing goods and services and making a profit.




Disadvantages of a market economy



In a market economy, where individuals and companies own assets, goods and services, profit is the priority, even though the prices of goods can be very high.

The production of goods and services to meet consumer preferences is competitive, and consumers may think ahead and engage in unhealthy work, leading to unemployment and layoffs.

A market economy is an economic system that emphasizes technology and consumer demand.



  1. Examples of Market Economies

  • Singapore
  • Hong Kong
  • New Zealand 
  • Switzerland
  • Australia
  • United States of America 



What is a planned economy?



A command economy is another economic system in which the state makes the decisions, and in this system, the laws of supply and demand play no role.




In a command economy, the political system is involved, the decision is made to mass-produce products regardless of consumer preferences, the goods and services produced are oversold, and the government sets prices with the goal of making them available to all citizens.


In a planned economy, prices are controlled by focusing on macroeconomic and social goals rather than on making a profit. Compared to a market economy, there are fewer incentives for efficient producers. Profits are made by the government.



Advantages of a planned economy



Planned economy avoids inequality by controlling prices and emphasizes social welfare rather than profit-seeking.

 It avoids or minimizes unhealthy business practices.

Prevents mass layoffs and unemployment.

 It also helps state-owned enterprises to overcome market failures.

In a planned economy, production is carried out according to a plan set by the government.

 It makes the best use of the country's capital and natural resources.

 It makes use of the abilities of each individual.

The main objective is to meet the basic needs of the country's population.



Weaknesses of a command economy 



In a command economy, SOEs have less information about the goods and services that consumers want.

In this case, they do not take into account the preferences or desires of consumers.

It does not support individual ideas or thoughts

It operates according to the government's plans.

In a command economy, the government has the power to make decisions and control the monopoly.



Examples of managed economies



Cuba

The country is run by the Cuban Communist Party, which was founded in 1965. The industry is centralized and controlled by the state with a central economic plan.




North Korea

North Korea is probably one of the most prominent examples of a command economy. It is very restrictive and controls the economy with an iron fist. Propaganda is equally strong, with the central authorities claiming they won the World Cup.




China

China is run by the Communist Party of China under President Xi, and while it is not as strict as a traditional communist country, it operates under strict central oversight and management. Foreign companies can only invest if they meet strict requirements while retaining control of most industries.




The Soviet Union

The Soviet Union was the gold standard of command economies in the twentieth century, with five-year economic plans, nationwide allocation of resources, and a notorious lack of choice in its society.




Characteristics of a Command Economy



Centralized Economic Planning

If a country's economy is centrally planned, then, of course, it needs a central economic plan, and so we think of the Soviet Union's Five-Year Economic Plan, implemented in 1928 under the leadership of Joseph Stalin.




Its purpose was to set goals for industry, for example, to increase coal production and agriculture, and then to allocate resources for that purpose. In fact, the Soviet Union was successful in some aspects of its economic plan, as it became a leader in the industry.




Government Allocation of Resources

The command economy had a central plan that was implemented through resource allocation, that is, the government directed work to where it saw fit, for example, people working in Moscow might move to Anadyr in the Russian Far East.




Monopolies

In a command economy, the government has a monopoly on all industries, which means that banking, manufacturing, utilities, and transportation are all centrally controlled. There is no competition, which means that all decisions are made by bureaucrats, rather than in response to competitive pressures.




The main differences between a market economy and a command economy are as follows.

The main difference between a market economy and a command economy is ownership and decision-making. A market economy is owned and decided by individuals, while a command economy is owned and decided by the government.

In a market economy, goods are provided taking into account consumer preferences, while in a command economy, consumer preferences are not taken into account.

A market economy encourages individual development and innovation, while a command economy discourages development and innovation or places little value on it.

A market economy has a weaker work ethic because it places more emphasis on market competition, while a command economy has a business model run by the government and reduces unemployment and unhealthy practices.

In a market economy, more emphasis is placed on profits, while in a command economy, more emphasis is placed on the welfare of the people.



Comments